Setting The Record straight: The Truth About The Louis Guthrie Because Truth Matters

May 12, 2012 3:06 pm 4 comments

After listening to Chris Baker, radio talk show host on KSEV, on the way home, and reading Davie Jennings’ article claiming a victory for Louis Guthrie in his recent court case contesting the circumstances under which he was fired from the Sheriff’s office, I do feel compelled to set the record straight, because, as Mr. Jennings says “Truth Matters”.

Please allow me to remind you why Mr. Guthrie was fired in the first place.  The ABC video, linked here, http://abclocal.go.com/ktrk/story?section=news/local&id=6800226 gives a good synopsis of the alleged official oppression charge of which Mr. Guthrie is accused, for shutting down a car wash business because he suspected that $17.00 had been stolen from his wife’s car.

The final court order has no reference to a victory for Louis Guthrie, nor does it say anything about being vindicated, getting his old job back, getting back pay, or any of the many other truth-stretching claims coming from Guthrie supporters.

To quote David Jennings, from Big Jolly Politics, in article dated May 6, 2012 http://www.bigjollypolitics.com/wp/2012/05/06/harris-county-sheriff-candidate-louis-guthrie-wins-appeal/:

Following a bench trial in District Court, Louis Guthrie was vindicated, and the Sheriff’s Civil Service Commission’s decision to uphold his firing was set aside and the case remanded for proceedings consistent with the Court’s Order. What does that mean? It means that after the Court found the Civil Service Commission, and vis-à-vis the Sheriff, had violated the Texas Government Code, the decision in violation of State Law was set aside. Louis should get his job back along with back pay and benefits.

Unfortunately, there is not much truth in the above statement, from Big Jolly Politics.

The actual court order is located here.

On April 16, 2012 a hearing was held in the 295th Civil District Court, Judge Caroline Baker presiding. The hearing was an appeal of the firing of Louis T. Guthrie from the Harris County Sheriff’s Office by Sheriff Adrian Garcia and upheld by the Harris County Civil Service Commission.

After hearing oral arguments from both sides, Mr. Guthrie and Harris County, Judge Baker made a ruling that the Civil Service Commission made an error in law by not addressing the issue of Mr. Guthrie not being provided a copy of the complaint. She therefore remanded the case back to Civil Service for further proceedings.

While this is a great victory for all employees of the Sheriff’s Office as this violation has been the norm in Internal Affairs investigations the battle is not over. There was nothing stated in the ruling absolving Mr. Guthrie of any of the actions for which he was investigated and terminated.

To quote the actual Order: “One of Guthrie’s grounds of error is that the disciplinary action taken against him was not in compliance with section 614.023 of the Texas Government Code and that this noncompliance requires the he be reinstated. Guthrie is correct in arguing that Chapter 614 of the Texas Government Code controls in cases such as this; however, the Court does not agree that such error requires it to order his reinstatement.”

It is apparent that the Court could find no error in his actual termination except for the technicality of not receiving a copy of the complaint which is a procedural error not necessarily an error in upholding the termination.

It is my understanding that Harris County is appealing this decision and knowing how the courts move a hearing on this appeal will in all likelihood be at some future date well past the primary and more than likely after the general election.

Should Harris County decide not to appeal the ruling and rehear the case in Civil Service, the Commission could still rule to uphold the termination. It would seem that to meet the requirements that Judge Baker remanded the case for all they would have to do is address the issue with the County Attorney to ensure that the Sheriff’s Office will in the future provide a copy of the complaint to employees involved in the future and provide Mr. Guthrie with a copy of his own at that time. This would meet the requirements set out in the Government Code and nullify the error in law.

To put all this in simpler terms, Mr. Guthrie’s case is far from over. He has not been absolved of any wrong doing in his actions for which he was terminated. While there is evidence and documentation that he did not violate the law it is entirely feasible that he did violate Harris County Sheriff’s Office’s departmental policy which could garner him disciplinary action from anything from documented counseling, letter of reprimand and/or suspension, and even termination. Mr. Guthrie still has an uphill battle with an unsure outcome. Remember you can win a battle and still lose the war.

Ref. 295th Harris County Civil District Court  case# 2010-35811

While I admire the enthusiasm of Mr. Guthrie’s supporters, I would ask them to restrain their comments to avoid being stretched to the point of prevarication.  This, unfortunately, is a common trait of some of Mr. Guthrie’s supporters.  A sure sign of desperation, and a losing campaign, when one has to lie in order to bolster their candidate’s credentials.

The actual court order is located here

4 Comments

  • Guthrie just sounds like an bully. I couldn’t believe that a guy that was fired from the Harris County Sheriffs Office for such abuses would actually come back and run for Sheriff. That takes some nerve.

  • Mr Guthrie does not exhibit the needed character to hold the office of Sheriff.
    Question – would the use of the rank “Lt.” be improper, due to his current status?
    Is the misuse of departmental resources, and essentially trumping up the incident, also covered under official oppression charges?
    To what charge will he be indicted once this takes place – I did not see an amount the charges are based (forgive me if I missed it). State Jail Felony?

  • Not only that, he’s hired a known and repeat offender image thief and copyright violator, Ms. Candice Schwager to work on his campaign.
    See below for the details and be sure to read the comments. Lots of online investigating went into calling her out for what she is, a liar and a thief!

    http://www.petapixel.com/2012/05/25/photographer-threatened-with-lawsuit-after-protecting-his-copyright/

    • Wow. Her comments are absolutely nuts. She is threatening to sue the person that she stole images from? Attacking the victim? This person really works for Guthrie, Al?

Leave a Reply


Trackbacks

Other News

  • Texas Senator Ken Paxton Endorsed By The Harris County Deputies’ Organization -HCDO

    Senator Ken Paxton Endorsed By The Harris County Deputies’ Organization -HCDO

    Harris County continues to unite in support of Ken Paxton for Attorney General! Just yesterday, Senator Ken Paxton announced another major law enforcement endorsement, gaining steam with an official nod from the Harris County Deputies’ Organization (HCDO). With nearly 1,700 members of Deputy Sheriffs and Deputy Constables, the Harris County Deputies’ Organization is the largest county Deputies’ organization in Texas.

    Harris County’s two largest law enforcement organizations – Houston Police Officers’ Union PAC and HCDO – have now endorsed Ken Paxton in his bid for Attorney General.

    Other endorsements since the primary include Dr. Steve Hotze, President of the Conservative Republicans of Texas

    Read more →
  • Dallas / Fort Worth Konni Burton Endorsed By Tarrant County Tax Assessor/Collector Ron Wright

    Konni Burton Endorsed By Tarrant County Tax Assessor/Collector Ron Wright

    Local leaders lining up behind Burton heading into May GOP runoff.

    FORT WORTH—Today the Konni Burton campaign announced the endorsement of Tax Assessor/Collector Ron Wright. Wright has been a public servant in Tarrant County for over three decades, serving as a member of the Arlington City Council, a weekly columnist for the Ft. Worth Star Telegram, and a long-time GOP leader and delegate to the Republican National Convention.

    In his endorsement, Mr. Wright offered his support stating, “Konni Burton is ready to take on the Democrats and restore conservative principles to Tarrant County. She’s built the wining team, the grassroots are behind her and she’s won the vote of so many in Tarrant County. We need to all unite behind Konni Burton, and take Senate District 10 back from the Democrats.”

    Read more →
  • Houston What is Senatorial District Seven going to do with all those Illegal aliens?  What path will Republicans choose today, for the future of Texas tomorrow?

    What is Senatorial District Seven going to do with all those Illegal aliens? What path will Republicans choose today, for the future of Texas tomorrow?

    What is Senatorial District Seven going to do with all those Illegal aliens? What path will Republicans choose today, for the future of Texas tomorrow?

    I have often spoken on this subject, and have discussed this issue with friend and foe alike, in both English as well as Spanish, and see this question as pivotal to the future of the Republican Party in Texas.

    What motivates me to address this topic today is something that occurred at our recent Harris County SD convention.

    On Saturday, March 22, the Harris County Republican Party convened the Senatorial District convention, where each senatorial district made decisions regarding the delegates and alternate delegates who will go to the state convention, and also chose the resolutions that will eventually make up the 2014 Texas Republican Party Platform.

    Read more →
  • Texas We Promised Momentum And Here It Is! – Ken Paxton For Texas Attorney General

    We Promised Momentum And Here It Is! – Ken Paxton For Texas Attorney General

    As many of us are at Republican county conventions today, I’m excited to report more momentum every day on the campaign trail.

    When the grassroots delivered us a stunning first-place finish in the Primary, I promised that we would build on that momentum and finish what we started. And we’re doing just that.

    Just yesterday we announced the official endorsement of former Harris County Tax Assessor, longtime conservative activist, and current State Senator-Elect Paul Bettencourt. The day before that we received very exciting news that Freedomworks, a nationwide grassroots organization that played an important role in electing Senator Ted Cruz, endorsed our campaign.

    Read more →
  • Texas And The Democrats Complain About The Koch Brothers?

    And The Democrats Complain About The Koch Brothers?

    A liberal California billionaire has pledged to spend $100 million to help elect Democrats that pledge to make “global warming” a priority.

    He seeks to elect only the most liberal of Democrats that are willing to sacrifice American prosperity for what the founder of the Weather Channel calls the “greatest scam in history”.

    Needless to say, our campaign will not see a dime of this money, but there is a strong possibility our opponent in November will. His background includes working in Clinton Administration (remember Al Gore?) and serving on the staff of Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee.

    Read more →